The SaaS Problem Nobody Talks About Honestly
Ask any IT leader how many SaaS applications their organization uses and you'll get a number. Ask their finance team the same question and you'll get a different number. Ask their procurement team and you'll get yet another. The uncomfortable truth is that nobody — not even the CIO — has a complete, accurate picture of the SaaS landscape.
This is SaaS sprawl. And it's not just an annoyance. It's a significant financial and security liability that most organizations are dramatically underestimating.
Average annual spend per employee on SaaS — most of which is never properly tracked or optimized.
Why SaaS Sprawl Gets So Bad
SaaS sprawl didn't happen overnight. It accumulated gradually through a combination of well-intentioned decisions and organizational blind spots:
- Departmental buying: Marketing, Sales, HR, and Finance have all been buying SaaS tools independently for years — often on credit cards, bypassing IT and procurement entirely.
- Free trials that never ended: Teams sign up for free plans, start paying, and the subscription lingers indefinitely because cancellation is never prioritized.
- Redundant capabilities: The average enterprise has 4–6 tools that all do roughly the same thing (project management, communication, file sharing) — purchased by different teams at different times.
- Employee turnover: When people leave, their SaaS subscriptions often stay active. One analysis found that 30% of SaaS spend is linked to ex-employees.
- COVID-era procurement: Remote work triggered a wave of rapid SaaS purchasing that was never fully reviewed or rationalized.
Key Insight: Most organizations discover that 30–40% of their SaaS applications are either completely unused or have usage so low they should be cancelled immediately. That's real money sitting on the table.
The 5-Step SaaS Rationalization Methodology
Here's the process we use at SAM Scholar to bring order to even the most complex SaaS environments. This isn't a one-time cleanup — it's a structured program that builds sustainable governance.
Discover Everything — Including the Shadow IT
You can't rationalize what you can't see. Step one is building a complete inventory of every SaaS application in your environment. This means going beyond the IT-approved app list. You need to scan expense reports, credit card statements, SSO logs, network traffic, and browser extensions. The goal is a single authoritative list of every tool being paid for or used — regardless of how it was procured. Tools like Zylo, BetterCloud, or even a thorough manual spend analysis can get you there.
Enrich With Usage Data
Having a list of applications is just the starting point. The real insight comes from overlaying usage data. For each application, you want to know: How many licenses were purchased? How many users actually logged in this month? Of those who logged in, how many are genuinely active users versus occasional visitors? Most SaaS vendors provide some form of usage reporting in their admin consoles. For others, SSO logs or API integrations can fill the gap. This data is where you'll find your biggest quick wins.
Score and Classify Every Application
With usage data in hand, classify every application using a simple framework. We typically use four categories: Keep (business-critical, well-utilized), Rightsize (valuable but over-licensed), Consolidate (duplicates an existing tool), and Retire (low or zero usage, no business justification). This classification is best done collaboratively with business stakeholders — IT shouldn't make these decisions unilaterally, or you'll face resistance when you try to act.
Execute the Optimization Plan
Now comes the actual work. For Rightsize candidates, negotiate down to your actual user count at the next renewal — don't let auto-renewals catch you off guard. For Consolidate candidates, run a structured process to choose the winner and migrate users off the duplicates with a clear timeline. For Retire candidates, communicate cancellation dates, ensure data is exported where needed, and cancel. This phase requires project management discipline and clear ownership to see it through.
Build Governance to Prevent Re-Sprawl
Rationalization without governance is just a one-time cleanup. Within 18 months, you'll be back where you started. Building sustainable SaaS governance means establishing a clear approval process for new SaaS purchases, creating a renewal calendar so nothing auto-renews unreviewed, assigning application ownership so someone is accountable for every tool, and running a quarterly usage review to catch creeping redundancy early. This is the step most organizations skip — and it's the reason why SaaS sprawl keeps coming back.
What Does Success Look Like?
Organizations that execute a thorough SaaS rationalization program typically achieve:
- A 40–60% reduction in the number of active SaaS applications
- 25–35% reduction in total SaaS spend within 12 months
- Elimination of most or all shadow IT apps (at least temporarily)
- A clear renewal calendar that prevents expensive auto-renewals
- Dramatically improved security posture from reduced app surface area
Real Result: One of our healthcare clients cut their active SaaS portfolio from 340 applications down to 187 in a single 90-day rationalization sprint — saving $1.2M annually and eliminating 153 unauthorized applications from their security risk register.
Getting Started
The hardest part of SaaS rationalization isn't the execution — it's starting. The most common reason organizations delay is because the scope feels overwhelming. Our advice: don't try to boil the ocean. Start with your top 20 applications by spend. Do a thorough usage analysis on just those 20. You'll almost certainly find $100K+ in immediate savings, which creates the momentum and organizational buy-in to tackle the rest.
If you want help running this process, or just want a second opinion on where to start — we're happy to spend 30 minutes on a free call to help you think it through.
Ready to Tackle Your SaaS Sprawl?
Book a free 30-minute assessment call. We'll review your current SaaS landscape and identify your top opportunities for immediate savings.
📅 Book a Free Call